1905 – 1987
American pacifist and the most committed non-Puerto Rican supporter of the Puerto Rican independence cause in the twentieth century. She ran the American League for Puerto Rico's Independence, was arrested during the 1950 Nationalist uprising, appeared before the United Nations to argue Puerto Rico's colonial status, and spent four decades making the case to American audiences that their government's rule over Puerto Rico was a violation of the same democratic principles the United States claimed to defend.
Ruth Mary Reynolds was born in 1905 in the United States and came to the cause of Puerto Rican independence through the broader currents of American pacifism and civil rights activism that shaped her political formation. She was associated with the War Resisters League, the Fellowship of Reconciliation, and other organisations of the American non-violent left — movements that understood imperialism and racial injustice as connected expressions of the same underlying problem and that were willing, in the 1940s and 1950s, to take positions that mainstream American liberalism found uncomfortable.
Her first serious engagement with Puerto Rico came in the early 1940s, when she began visiting the island and meeting the figures of the independence movement. She was drawn particularly to Pedro Albizu Campos — whose combination of legal precision, moral intensity, and willingness to accept personal sacrifice she found compelling — and to the broader Nationalist tradition. She became, over the following decades, one of the movement's most effective advocates to American audiences: a white American woman who could speak to constituencies the Puerto Rican independence movement could not easily reach, translating the colonial reality of the island into language that American civil libertarians and peace activists could recognise and engage with.
Reynolds became the driving force behind the American League for Puerto Rico's Independence — an organisation that worked to build support for Puerto Rican self-determination within the United States itself, arguing to American audiences that their country's rule over Puerto Rico was inconsistent with the democratic values the United States claimed to embody. The work was not glamorous. It involved writing, speaking, organising meetings, producing literature, maintaining connections between the independence movement and sympathetic Americans, and sustaining pressure on politicians and institutions that preferred to ignore the issue.
The League operated in a hostile political environment. The McCarthy era made advocacy of any position that the government associated with communism — and the independence movement, with its connections to Cuba and its critique of American foreign policy, was routinely so associated — professionally and personally dangerous. Reynolds accepted that risk. She was surveilled by the FBI, which maintained extensive files on her activities and connections. She was regarded by federal authorities as a national security concern for her advocacy of a position that was, by any reasonable measure, consistent with the principles of democratic self-determination that American foreign policy officially championed everywhere except Puerto Rico.
Reynolds was in Puerto Rico when the October 1950 Nationalist uprising began. She was present in Jayuya in the days surrounding Blanca Canales's declaration of the republic and the National Guard's response. She was arrested by Puerto Rican authorities and charged with failing to register as an agent of a foreign principal — the legal theory being that her advocacy for Puerto Rican independence made her an agent of a foreign power, though which foreign power was never made entirely clear. The charge was constitutionally dubious and was eventually dropped, but not before Reynolds had experienced firsthand the manner in which the colonial government used the legal system to suppress political expression.
Her arrest and the publicity surrounding it served, in the event, to amplify rather than silence her advocacy. She was an American citizen, arrested on American-controlled territory for political advocacy — a fact that brought the repressive character of the Gag Law regime to the attention of American civil liberties organisations in a way that arrests of Puerto Rican citizens had not. Her case became a small cause in American civil liberties circles, adding another thread to the fabric of mainland awareness of Puerto Rican political conditions.
Reynolds was a persistent presence at United Nations proceedings concerning Puerto Rico's decolonisation status. The United Nations had established a Special Committee on Decolonisation, and the question of whether Puerto Rico's 1952 Commonwealth reorganisation had genuinely resolved its colonial status was a recurring item before that committee. Reynolds appeared, testified, provided documentation, and argued — year after year — that the Commonwealth was a colonial relationship with better public relations, and that Puerto Ricans had not been given a genuine free choice between independence, statehood, and continued association with the United States.
The United Nations Special Committee passed resolutions affirming Puerto Rico's right to self-determination repeatedly — resolutions the United States consistently opposed but which kept the issue on the international decolonisation agenda. Reynolds's contribution to this process was the sustained, unglamorous work of maintaining the argument and keeping the documentation current through decades when the independence cause was not generating the dramatic actions that attracted international attention.
Ruth Mary Reynolds occupies a distinctive position in the history of the Puerto Rican independence movement as its most committed non-Puerto Rican supporter — and that distinctiveness raises questions that her story makes visible rather than resolves. What does it mean for an American to devote her life to fighting American imperialism in Puerto Rico? Is the solidarity genuine, or does it replicate, in however well-intentioned a form, the American presumption that Puerto Rican causes require American advocates to be taken seriously?
Reynolds herself was aware of these tensions and navigated them with the humility that her long relationship with the movement — and the trust that Albizu Campos, Corretjer, and others extended to her — suggests she earned. She understood that the cause was Puerto Rican, that her role was to amplify rather than lead, and that the specific value she brought was her ability to reach American audiences and institutions that the movement could not reach on its own. Whether that value outweighed the symbolic costs of an American woman being the movement's most visible mainland advocate is a question the movement itself debated, and no answer has been settled.
Ruth Mary Reynolds died in 1987 at eighty-one years old. She had spent more than four decades advocating for a cause she had chosen as her own across every boundary — of nationality, of personal risk, of professional consequence — that stood between her and it. Puerto Rico had not achieved independence. But the argument that it should had been made, with her help, in every forum where it could be heard. She is remembered within the Puerto Rican independence movement as one of the few outsiders who earned genuine trust — a woman who showed that solidarity, when it is consistent and sustained and humble, can cross the lines that divide the coloniser's country from the colonised.
Choose which cookies you're happy for us to use. You can change this at any time from the "Cookie Settings" link in the footer.